|
"Be careful of your thoughts, for your thoughts become
your words.
Be careful of your words, for your words become your actions.
Be careful of your actions, for your actions become your habits.
Be careful of your habits, for your habits become your character.
Be careful of your character, for your character becomes your
destiny."
- Anonymous
|
|
Defining
Virtues |
|
The English word "virtue" is
derived from the Latin, vir (man, male, masculine). This explains
why virtus, the Latin word for virtue, is defined as "manly
strength,""manly courage" or "manly excellence."
Of course, this is not to say that the term virtue is applied to men
alone. Virtue includes both genders, male and female. |
|
For good list of the traditional
virtues that flourished in ancient Greece and Rome and thereafter,
go to :
|
|
|
|
Aristotle was
the first theorist of virtue ethics or arete which we translate
as excellence. For him, possessing the moral virtues or
moral excellences, such as moderation, is the way that one leads "the
good life." Courage, temperance, strength of character, justice
and so on are often identified as desirable habits for people to develop
and which, when cultivated well, would lead one to the path of excellence
arete. |
|
For an in-depth
look at Aristotles view of virtue theory read the following
website by Dr. Charles Ess, Philosophy and Religion Department, Drury
University. Go to: |
|
http://www.drury.edu/ess/Reason/Aristotle.html |
|
A
more complete definition of "virtue," therefore, would be
that virtue is a disposition, or a capacity, or an attitude by which
a person is moved to seek and carry out ethically good or morally
good acts. As virtue develops, it becomes a habitual and firm disposition
that stands in the face of obstacles even at the cost of sacrifice.
To develop virtue can be challenging and painstaking over time. It
is not something that we develop once and for all. It must be constantly
and consistently worked on to be sustained and developed. |
|
|
Find a good definition and
historical overview of virtue theory in the Internet Encyclopedia
of Philosophy at: |
|
http://www.utm.edu/research/iep/v/virtue.htm |
|
Using
Virtues |
|
The lead virtue questions in a VCR analysis are:
|
|
|
What virtues should be
exemplified by the main professionals in the issue, problem, or
dilemma?
|
|
|
What is the most excellent
course of action that can be taken by them in the situation?
|
|
|
This second step in the VCR
analytic framework for ethical decision-making is the application
of virtue ethics. What is emphasized here is a set of desirable character
traits, or excellences, and our actions are gauged according to whether
certain virtues that make out a good character are promoted by our
actions or not. |
|
Some ethicists who hold the
virtue theory claim that a person's character functions dispositionally
in such a way that people engage in ethical or unethical conduct thanks
to the character traits that they have developed in their lives. A
good character will dispose one to virtuous acts, while a morally
deficient character will dispose one to unethical acts. |
|
While virtue ethics normally
refers to the way individual people behave, it can also be used in
an analysis of a professional ethical issue, problem or dilemma. We
can ask if a profession or a professional has acted in such a way
as to promote a particular virtue or not. We can also ask if resolving
a professional moral maze in a certain way will result in a judgment
of being virtuous. Thus, if we keep in mind what would count as virtuous
acts in the professions, then we can make judgments about the ethics
of professionals. We can ask if the conduct of professionals promoted
excellence in their profession or not. |
|
|
Exercise: |
|
Should
virtues be taught in public schools? In the country that you are from,
do the public schools already include the teaching of virtues to children?
Should such virtues as moderation, justice or strength of character
be taught in these
public schools? Why or why not? Are their other virtues that you would
recommend be taught? Why are these good candidates?
|
|
More on Virtues |
|
Here
are some other websites for you to explore that deal with this second
aspect of the VCR approach to ethics: |
|
|
Read a book
review of Ethics and Excellence by Robert Solomon which advocates
the use of virtue ethics in business: |
|
http://web.sau.edu/RichardsRandyL/business_ethics_filing_cabinet_ethics_and_excellence_beck_dudley.htm |
|
Listen to
a Real Audio interview with Matt Ridley on "The Origins of Virtue."
The program is a segment of "Ideas and Issues" from WETS-FM
at East Tennessee State University. Hugh LaFollette conducts the interview.
Ridley is a biologist interested in the evolutionary sources for virtue,
in particular the virtue of cooperation. |
|
http://www.hughlafollette.com/radio/ridley.htm |
|